Election View from the Isle of Axholme

09 May 2011 by Simon Brears

It may surprise some people in North Lincolnshire to know that the council boundaries extends west of the River Trent. Just over the King George V bridge lies a collection of villages and small towns known as the Isle of Axholme. This often overlooked part of North Lincolnshire provided the sole Labour Councillor outside of Scunthorpe after last weeks elections. Many parts of the Isle are not traditionally Labour areas. Indeed the Conservative leader, Liz Redfern, was elected from Axholme Central. But to take back the Council in 2015 it is places like Axholme North where Labour needs to win. The Isle faces a number of ways and sometimes it's connection to what goes on in Scunthorpe is not an obvious one. In the south of the Isle there is a greater affinity to Doncaster, due in no small part to its proximity to South Yorkshire and the number of families which make the move across the border. Further northwards Goole becomes closer to travel to than Scunthorpe. The Isle of Axholme was a constituent part of Boothferry Borough Council before the demise of Humberside, linking us with Goole, Snaith and Howden. This disconnection from Scunthorpe is often exploited by Tories. The election in the Isle was not an easy one. The Conservatives were well aware they lost control of the council in 2007 because of the Labour victory in the Axholme North. While our local Labour team had a small group of committed and hard working activists, we were consistently out spent and out manned by the Tories. They had shipped students from the other side of the Humber to help deliver leaflets, knock doors and sit on polling stations. The two candidates, Trev Barker and Paul McCartan, put in a sterling effort. There was a dramatically increased turnout from four years ago, thanks to the energetic campaign from Paul, Trevor and the whole team. This saw Trevor Barker's vote increase by around 200 from 2007. But the end result was a mixed bag. Trevor secured a decisive victory, but Paul was just short of being elected. On the night of the count it was an early set back for the Tories who were sure of a double win in Axholme North. Our result however didn't affect the outcome as the three Winterton seats swung the council to the Conservatives. While I can't speak for Winterton the tactic of the Tories in Axholme North was to make it a contest between the Scunthorpe Labour Party and the rural Conservative Party. They played on the misconception that rural tax payers money funds investment in Scunthorpe, the Baths Hall and the Pods coming in for heavy criticism. This was the same strategy they deployed in 2003-2007 that disastrously blew up in their faces when they realised that rural residents also visited the Film Theatre and the old Baths Hall. While there may be a few Labour councillors scratching their heads this morning about what went wrong one fact remains: it is still very easy for the Tories to play the villages off against Scunthorpe. Naturally as the Labour Group is mainly drawn from Scunthorpe it lacks both attachment to rural areas and an understanding of what living in a rural community is like. Therefore an impression is created that they don't care about us in Isle, even if this far from the case. But it remains true that there is an inward looking element to the Labour members in Pittwood House. The attitudes expressed by certain councillors about us countryside dwellers leaves a lot to be desired. I am not revealing state secrets when I say that help was not as forth coming as it should have been during the election for the Isle. This was a result of the close general election result for Nic Dakin in Scunthorpe last year and the need to ensure town wards didn't go blue. But there was not a recognition till it was too late that Labour needed the villages to keep their majority. Our win in Axholme North demonstrates that rural areas are not the sole preserve of the Conservative Party. Idyllic images of the countryside hide serious social problems. As in other parts of the country villages are increasingly being turned from working farming communities to commuter towns. This has been accelerated by the building of 'Ben Bailey' estates up and down the Isle, passed by a Labour controlled planning committee. The new estates have acted to widen existing social divisions in villages. It masks the extensive rural poverty in the Isle, with problems that sometimes mirror disadvantaged communities in Scunthorpe. Chief among these is unemployment which forces young people out of the areas they grew up in to find work. Transport links in the Isle are extremely poor and expensive in comparison to Scunthorpe. Lack of transport coupled with a shortage of local jobs creates barriers to employment for those who are most disadvantaged. Transport also limits the access of school children to further education in town and results in the isolation of the elderly. Affordable homes is another concern for villages with social housing being in short supply. These are not problems that the Conservative Party in North Lincolnshire will ever resolve, certainly not in my home town of Crowle. Apart from the slash and burn budget they will no doubt bring forward, they have a habit of punishing areas which dare to vote Labour. But issues in disadvantaged rural communities should be as much a priority for Labour as those in urban areas. Labour needs to realise that without the votes of rural residents they will never be able to deliver change for all of North Lincolnshire. Isle of Axholme Labour Party member


If you would like add your own news article to Visit Scunthorpe, Login or sign up, its free and easy and you can start publishing your own content here, straight away.


Comments


Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Black Flag 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
I fear Simon over eggs the pudding with regard to the rural disadvantaged. Many villages in rural areas are now commuter villages - they are great places to live and people are prepared to pay the price for the properties - this is the free market at work. If you knuckle down, get a good education and a good job then you too can afford to live in the village you grew up in and commute to town for work (whether that be Scunny, Goole or more likely Donny). For those who cannot get work locally then sell-up to someone who can and move to where the work is! It is also clear to me that there is a clear idealogical divide between the majority of residents in the villages and those in town. If the straight jacket of a unitary authority structure, and the prospect of a Tory led council irks the inhabitants of Scunthorpe then why not petition for a town council and repatriate as many powers to it as possible. An example of this is Weston-Super_Mare. a former borough town that refused to be swallowed up by the North Somerset unitary authority and became a town council in 2000 town of 79k who broke away from The example of this

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Black Flag 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
I hope that when the new improved Visit Scunthorpe site arrives it has a review posting before publishing feature for the duffers like me who can't type :-) Ignore the superfluous "town of 79k who broke away from The example of this"

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Thoades 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
Interesting points Black Flag. Especially with the Western-Super-Mere example, I was unaware of that. Don't know if you are aware, but on Wed evening there is a meeting of the Scunthorpe Coalition of Resistance to discuss effects of cuts, you may find it interesting to go along and take part in the discussions, I hope to providing I get finished at work in time.

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Thoades 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
lol @ usability issue, yes m8, the new version is much improved, we'll be rolling out a beta test very soon for feedback specifically on the poster's interface, if you'd like to help and do some testing we'd really appreciate it, email Editors@visitScunthorpe.Com and we'll send u a link when it's done Same goes for any one else wishing to take part. We'll put a credit on the site's about us page thanking all testers.

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Simon Brears 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
The point about a town council for Scunthorpe is a valid one. It is not an easy process however. Signatures have to be collected of 10% of electors in an affected area - for Scunthorpe that would be in 7,000. Even then it is reliant on the a government minister giving approval. They tend to favour smaller parishes too. Also I think Black Flag has a fundamental misunderstanding about what rural poverty is actually like in the Isle. For people living in Keadby, Luddington, Garthorpe or even Crowle what you suggest isn't an option. Moving to where the work is incurs its own costs. If you live in an isolated village you'd be lucky if there is a bus that will take you to the Job Centre to sign on let alone up root your family and move. Further to this why should living close to your family, in the place you grew up only be an option for those can afford inflated house prices?

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Black Flag 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
As resident of one of the local villages you would have expected me to be able to get to the Coalition of Resistance meeting however as one of the disadvantaged who can't get a local job I have to commute to/from Leeds and I will not be able to make it. Apart from my shared disgust at cuts to care homes, I don't see what the urgency is - we have yet to see the Tories Emergency Budget. Unlike Labour, who cut services to the vunerable for what they hoped would be a political gain, the Tories have aimed to work with other councils to amalgamate the provision of services across county boundaries to cut costs. This is usually aimed at functions such as legal, IT, procurement etc - not essential front line services.

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Thoades 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
Rural poverty in north Lincolnshire is something I'd be interested in learning more about. Many of us think of the villages being affluent, but I'd imagine on reflections there are those areas which are underprivileged just as there are in urban areas. I must admit I'd been ignorant of the terrible extent of child poverty in Scunthorpe until a reader emailed in suggesting an article on it. This is certainly an area which is worthy of more detailed investigation.

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Black Flag 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
Simon, If those eastern europeans managed to get off their butt, uproot to Scunthorpe and get work in the food production, distribution and retailing industries, enabling them to rent properties locally and run cars then why can't the local population do the same?

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Simon Brears 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
VANL produced a report on rural poverty in North Lincs and North East Lincs below: http://www.vanl.org.uk/images/stories/publications/rural-gap.pdf It identifies Axholme North as having a number of problems which include being in the top 5% of places in the country that experience the highest level of fuel poverty.

Reply   Report   

Up vote this comment
Down vote this comment
[-]Comments hidden, click to expand. (1|0) By Thoades 1 year ago (1|0)Rated: Great!
Cheers Simon, When I get a chance I'll look through it and do a summary for readers, very busy over the next two weeks though with the new site, so if any other reader's fancy having a go, please do I'll be unable to do it quickly.

Reply   Report   

If you would like to leave a comment about this article, Login or sign up now


Please Note

Views expressed on this site are those of individual posters, who by making these posts indemnify Visit Scunthorpe and its operators of any legal responsibility or obligation.
Please respect the privacy of others, if someone gives you infomation that you use in your post, please don't identify them.

Complete site map of Visit Scunthorpe.Com

Add an Article

Site map

Mission Statement

Visit Scunthorpe is North Lincolnshire's only truly independent, non commercial, community news web site.

Established in January 2010 we have lots of members with a wide range of views who all contribute independently with articles of their own.

You won't find dozens of adverts covering our site, or some poor attempt to promote local business services under the guise of offering a community service.

Here on VisitScunthorpe we are interested in just one thing, building an online community which is representative of the people of Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire and the surrounding area.

Paul. Founder Visit Scunthorpe.

How it Works

If you would like to have the ability to add articles and comments to Visit Scunthorpe then all you need to do is sign up with a valid email address for an account. This is free, your email address is confidential and we don't send out spam emails.

Once you've completed the sign up then you are free to post and comment on well... pretty much anything, we just have some basic civilised rules to prevent people from inciting violence, hatred or making individual attacks.

Business Directory for Scunthorpe, South Humberside

If you have a web site or directory which covers either independent news and blogging, or is related to North Lincolnshire or Scunthorpe then get in touch to set up a reciprocal link.

Choose your smiley!

smile suprised tongue big grin confused cool cry drool happy mad sad sleepy
×

You need to be logged in to do that!

Not got an account ? Click here to sign up.

×

Report Comment

State your reasons for the report and we'll take a look at the comment right away.

×
Page executed and compiled in 0.0527 seconds.